After a return to kind in quantity eight, My Next Life as a Villainess: All Routes Lead to Doom! takes one other slide downhill within the ninth novel. It’s not almost as egregious as what we noticed in books six and 7, the 2 tales that arrange the concept that there was a second Fortune Lover sport after Katarina’s dying in her earlier life, so that is actually extra of a slip than an out-and-out tumble. In giant half that is as a result of, like with the eighth e-book, the main target stays totally on the solid of the sooner novels, simply pared all the way down to Katarina’s two primary coworkers on the Ministry: Maria and Sora.
This is, when it comes to the love pursuits, very a lot their e-book. Not that Katarina is conscious of it; she’s nonetheless satisfied that Maria wants to finish up with one of many targets from Fortune Lover and has determined that the existence of the second sport signifies that one in every of these guys are going to be her real love. She thus takes this journey as an indication that Sora and Maria are going to make progress of their romance, blissfully unaware that the one romance both of them are inquisitive about progressing is together with her.
It’s a particular energy of the novel that creator Satoru Yamaguchi stops flirting round with Maria’s emotions and at last simply flat-out admits that Maria is romantically drawn to Katarina. (There does not appear to be a sexual part, differentiating her from Mary.) Even Sora notices Maria’s emotions, which definitely appears to point that Maria herself has reached the purpose the place she’s able to admit to herself what her feelings are. Not that she hid them earlier than, however it actually looks like she herself turns into totally conscious of her personal feelings on this quantity. There’s one thing very rewarding about that, even when Maria and Katarina aren’t your most well-liked ship, as a result of it looks like the primary actual character growth Maria’s gotten shortly.
Interestingly sufficient, neither Maria nor Sora looks like they’ve an precise likelihood with Katarina. Both of them seem to agree that the lead contenders for her coronary heart are Jeord and Keith. Jeord definitely is smart; he is her precise fiancé and he has not been delicate about reminding folks of the very fact. Keith feels a bit of extra shocking on the floor. After all, so far as anybody is aware of he is her brother (I’m unsure anybody actually is aware of he is adopted; even when Mary, Alan, Jeord, Sophia, and Nichol know, Raphael, Maria, and Sora might not), however he is additionally the particular person with probably the most unfettered entry to her, in addition to probably the most outspoken opposition to Jeord. But this concept that solely two of the various aspirants to Katarina’s affections have any actual likelihood feels very very similar to a marker of Maria and Sora’s late entry on the scene. I feel you would be hard-pressed to search out Mary expressing any such ideas. From the viewpoint of the brand new characters on this quantity, nonetheless, Sora appears to be like like the highest contender – largely as a result of he is a person and individuals who aren’t Sora misread Maria’s actions as being platonically motivated. (Sora harbors no such illusions.) This does not appear to be something however an announcement about in-world biases, although, and neither Maria nor Sora take Maria’s gender into consideration once they’re fascinated by who has an opportunity with Katarina.
Even although Maria and Sora are the romantic pursuits who get the quantity with our clueless heroine, the storyline is not technically about them. The plot is that the Magical Ministry has tracked down the coastal city the place the human traffickers are lively, and Larna takes the opposite three alongside together with her to analyze. They’re meant to work undercover at a restaurant managed by one other Ministry member, listening for any information whereas Sora additionally works on the docks to do the identical. Everyone is nervous about letting Katarina, the daughter of a duke, do guide labor (apparently they forgot the farming?), however she’s insistent, and because it seems, she’s a a lot better waitress than she is a noblewoman. But extra importantly to the plot, she additionally befriends Arneau, a member of the trafficking gang, which results in her truly getting the primary job finished.
What’s vital to notice is that Arneau does not change into one other member of her harem. He likes her, however not romantically; it is extra that he is impressed together with her kindness, since as an orphan within the slums he is barely skilled any. There’s additionally a hyperlink between Arneau and Sora, which signifies that even when he did have a crush on her, Arneau would by no means act on it. He’s not a second Nichol, nonetheless – he is truly a really unhappy case, somebody who does not consider in his personal price and thinks that he does not deserve any pleasure in his life. Katarina’s function is not to attraction him, it is to assist him to grasp that he is not as dangerous as he thinks, and even then, it is extra Sora and Cezare who try this. Arneau is not a throwaway character, however he is also markedly completely different in the way in which that he treats and feels about Katarina.
The ninth novel within the collection is not horrible. It has some very candy moments, some humorous ones, and it exhibits Yamaguchi making an attempt to department out a bit when it comes to writing type. But it additionally is not fairly nearly as good because the earlier e-book, and whereas Maria is good and beautiful, she’s not assertive sufficient to play in opposition to Katarina in the way in which that the opposite characters are. The web page depend additionally feels a bit decrease than different novels, so there merely is not the area to do as a lot storytelling because the plot deserves. It’s nonetheless an entertaining e-book, simply lower than the heights of the sooner volumes. Hopefully it’s going to return to kind in novel ten.