Earlier this yr, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone celebrated its 2oth anniversary with a reunion particular, Return to Hogwarts. It noticed a number of of the primary forged reunite to debate their reminiscences of constructing the wildly standard film collection and confirmed simply how shut actors like Emma Watson, Rupert Grint, and Daniel Radcliffe had change into. It additionally answered many behind-the-scenes questions audiences had by no means had a solution to.
However, even all these years later, Harry Potter followers have discovered that they nonetheless have some unanswered questions concerning the plot of Sorcerer’s Stone. Some of those arose years later when future installments offered odd contradictions, whereas different facets of the movie made no sense to audiences from day one. Fans on Reddit posed a few of their largest questions on the primary Harry Potter film and the e book in hopes that somebody might need some solutions.
Was Dumbledore Baiting Voldemort?
When Sorcerer’s Stone was first launched, audiences could not assist however chuckle at how simple it was for Harry, Ron, and Hermione to get previous the protections guarding the Stone. Dumbledore and McGonagall had been so assured that it was protected, but three 11-year-old kids might entry it with no drawback.
As the collection continued, nevertheless, it turned clear that Dumbledore did nothing by chance. So now, Redditors like AnEndlesWaltz are asking: “did Albus bait [Voldemort] with the stone to try to thwart him?” If that have been the case, Dumbledore would have purposely made the obstacles simple, apart from the Mirror, which was the one correct safety. It’s doable that the mixture of Harry and the Stone was simply bait to get Voldemort out of hiding.
How Did Quirrell Find Voldemort?
Professor Quirrell was described as a intelligent man desirous to show himself. To try this, he tracked down the whereabouts of the Harry Potter villain Lord Voldemort and ended up possessed by him. But AnEndlessWaltz is confused about how Quirrell might have managed this.
“Bellatrix boasted that she looked the longest/most out of anyone,” they mentioned. If highly effective wizards like Bellatrix, her husband, and Barty Crouch Jr could not discover Voldemort, a younger, fresh-out-of-school wizard could not have both. Perhaps if Dumbledore hoped to lure Voldemort out of hiding, he gave Quirrell just a little nudge, however that will have been heartless even for him.
Why Was Hermione Afraid Of Voldemort’s Name?
When Harry first began interacting with the wizarding world in Sorcerer’s Stone, he usually forgot that it was taboo to say the title Voldemort. He had been raised by Muggles, so though the Dark wizard had murdered his dad and mom, he did not have an issue saying his title.
However, Hermione was additionally raised by Muggles, but she was instantly afraid to say the title. “She would only know of him through books, but she wouldn’t really understand the fear of him,” mentioned Redditor Proro. Perhaps she had simply been performing to higher slot in, however that does not appear very similar to Hermione, who was typically wise in Harry Potter.
Why Would Dumbledore Use The Deluminator?
When Dumbledore appeared on Privet Drive firstly of Sorcerer’s Stone, he pulled out his magical Deluminator and put out all the road lights. This was carried out so he might keep away from sneaky eyes seeing him out the window, however Redditor 3oblins was confused by this determination.
“It shot bright lights across everyone’s windows in the middle of the night,” they identified, questioning how Dumbledore thought that that will be much less suspicious than a unusually dressed man on the street. But, in the end, it could have simply been Dumbledore’s flashiness that impressed him to make use of his nifty instrument.
Is Gringotts Really the Only Wizarding Bank?
In the e book, Harry was shocked to study that wizards had banks, however Hagrid clarified that there’s “only one.” He was referring, in fact, to Gringotts Bank. However, as audiences have realized extra concerning the wizarding world, it appears unusual that there can be a single financial institution for everybody to make use of.
Redditor TheHammerIsMy requested if Hagrid had meant there was solely the financial institution in Diagon Alley or if he had meant that “there’s just one bank company but several locations?” This could possibly be the case, as Bill Weasley labored for Gringotts and traveled the world, but it surely appears there is no such thing as a option to know for positive.
Why Did Scabbers Bite Goyle?
In the Philosopher’s Stone e book, Malfoy, Crabbe, and Goyle launched themselves to Harry and Ron on the practice trip to Hogwarts. Once Harry had turned down Malfoy’s invitation for friendship, the bullying began, and Goyle reached to take a few of their snacks for himself. However, Scabbers saved the say and bit his finger moderately severely.
Of course, years later, audiences study that Scabbers was, in reality, a Death Eater in disguise. This led Redditor TheHammerIsMy to ask if Scabbers, or Peter Pettigrew, “hates Goyle for some reason?” It could possibly be that Scabbers feared him because the son of one other Death Eater, or possibly he simply did not need anybody to take his snacks.
How Does The School Track Students?
Before Hagrid mentioned the well-known line “Yer a wizard, Harry,” the Boy Who Lived obtained a number of hundred letters from Hogwarts. The first one had recognized that Harry lived within the cabinet underneath the steps, however within the e book, every subsequent letter mentioned no matter location the Dursleys had moved him to inside the home.
At the time, this appeared like some charming magic, but it surely raised questions for Redditors like Eyl327. “Shouldn’t they be able to know when he’s not in the common room?” they requested, declaring that if there may be magic to pinpoint the place a scholar is in a Muggle home, the magical fortress ought to have had higher tabs on its college students.
How Did Hagrid Not Get Caught?
When Hagrid picks Harry up from the island shack firstly of Sorcerer’s Stone, he makes use of fairly a little bit of magic. First, he makes use of no matter sort of enchantment to entry the hut. Then, he lights a fireplace and tries to show Dudley right into a pig. He tells Harry to not repeat all of this to anybody since he is not allowed to do magic. It was considered one of Hagrid’s best moments in Harry Potter, but it surely raised just a few questions.
Audiences later study that the Ministry of Magic tracks magic use, particularly in Muggle areas. Redditor Eyl327 requested why the Ministry did not discover magic getting used “illegally in front of Muggles.” It’s doable that that space was too distant for them to see, or possibly Dumbledore someway intervened.
Why Didn’t Snape Magically Heal His Leg?
After the occasions of Halloween, the Golden Trio observed that Snape had a nasty gash on his leg that led him to limp for the following couple of weeks. This made Harry suppose that Snape was the one attempting to get the Sorcerer’s Stone since he had tried to get previous Fluffy.
Of course, they later discover out that Snape’s twist ending in Sorcerer’s Stone was that he was solely attempting to cease Quirrell, however that does not reply Redditor HarryPotterCupcake‘s query: “why doesn’t Snape have Madam Pomfrey fix his leg, or fix it himself?” It is evident from later installments that Snape is succesful, however possibly Fluffy’s saliva has magical properties that maintain a wound from being healed.
Why Would Students Be Sent Into The Forest?
Harry’s first detention at Hogwarts resulted from sneaking out of the fortress at evening, and he spent it within the Forbidden Forest with Hagrid. Of course, this was when he first bought a take a look at Voldemort himself and got here very near being killed if Firenze the centaur hadn’t intervened.
This has at all times perplexed audiences, who’ve discovered it unusual that McGonagall would ship college students right into a forbidden location as punishment for breaking the principles. “Surely they can be of no help to Hagrid and can only get into more danger,” mentioned Redditor Rumblemuffin. Maybe this was yet one more plan of Dumbledore’s to check the sort of person who Harry had change into.