It’s arduous to carry Harry to a better normal than the numerous adults who surrounded him in his fourth 12 months at Hogwarts in Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire, he is the protagonist. Perhaps Dumbledore ought to have seen that the pal he employed to show Defense Against the Dark Arts was not likely the pal he claimed to be.
Anyway, Harry additionally spent what gave the impression to be a number of additional time with Professor Alastor “Mad-Eye” Moody than lots of his classmates and possibly a number of the school. Harry Potter suspects Malfoy of nefarious exercise if the boy sneezes, however he appears to have missed just a few key clues when it got here to the false Professor Moody.
Updated on December twenty fifth, 2021 by Melody MacReady: It is nicely established that Harry Potter is way from an skilled on issues within the Wizarding World, contemplating he is lived with muggles his entire life and spends his time within the muggle world outdoors of faculty. However, Harry Potter proves to be one of many worst detectives when it got here to Alastor “Mad-Eye” Moody being Barty Crouch Jr. in disguise.
The character has so many hints and tells that time to him not being who he says that even Harry Potter ought to have seen. Harry Potter might need been distracted by the Triwizard Tournament however there have been loads of unsubtle indicators each within the e book and movie that any fan might decide up on.
Never Said Anything About A Graveyard
The solely clue Harry even remotely hones in on is after he is already been portkeyed away and met up with a now resurrected Lord Voldemort. Only now, when he realizes one thing was improper all alongside does he even elevate his head and think about that possibly there’s one thing a little bit off about Moody.
Still, he is not in a position to put the items collectively, that Moody is not actually Moody till that polyjuice potion wears off. He ought to have caught on a bit sooner.
He Saw Crouch And Moody In The Pensieve
When Harry visits Dumbledore’s workplace and is left alone with Fawkes, one of the cutest magical creatures, he by chance stumbles onto Dumbledore’s Pensieve after which by chance stumbles into Dumbledore’s recollections. The reminiscence we see within the movie stars each the actual Mad-Eye Moody and Barty Crouch Jr.
Despite this introduction to the actual Alastor Moody, and the actual Barty Crouch Jr. Harry would not as soon as put any items collectively or ask any significant questions. Instead, he is extra involved about his unusual goals.
The Encounter Between Moody And Barty Crouch
One of the most important giveaways that Moody was not who he gave the impression to be was when Barty Crouch Sr. and Moody had a short dialog after the second activity. Not solely does Moody randomly chastize Barty Crouch Sr. for seemingly no cause however he flicks his tongue like a snake.
Barty Crouch Sr. instantly acknowledges this tic and appears horrified by it earlier than strolling away. Also, the very subsequent time Harry Potter sees Barty Crouch Sr., he occurs to be useless. Considering that Alastor Moody is already off-putting by that time, Harry ought to have no less than suspected foul play from the Auror.
Barty Crouch Sr. Dies Almost Immediately After Speaking With Moody
So, after their unusual interplay, Barty Crouch Sr. is discovered useless within the Forbidden Forest within the very subsequent scene. Obviously, there is no such thing as a direct proof pointing in direction of Moody however Harry ought to have no less than suspected Moody to have been concerned after seeing Crouch react to Moody in such a weird method.
In the e book model of Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire, Moody unexpectedly exhibits up after Barty Crouch Sr. is discovered useless. No one despatched for Moody, solely Dumbledore. How did he simply occur to be in the proper place on the proper time? Did he overhear the data?
Moody presents Harry an terrible lot of assist with regards to the completely different duties within the Triwizard Tournament. This wouldn’t be terribly suspicious if Harry have been the one Hogwarts champion however Cedric Diggory can also be concerned. Why was Moody so biased to assist Harry?
Not as soon as does Moody attempt to assist Cedric, the opposite consultant of Hogwarts within the Triwizard Tournament. Though Harry in all probability appreciated the assistance, he ought to have no less than questioned why Moody was so concerned along with his aspect of the event.
The actual Alastor Moody was identified for ingesting from a hip flask to keep away from being poisoned by his enemies however the Moody that Harry interacts with is a bit obsessed along with his drink and guzzles between meals and in corridors.
It’s a type of disturbing behavior and once more, Harry simply goes with it after acknowledging it solely as soon as. The flask is one thing Harry notices no less than, although he by no means places it along with the opposite clues surrounding him to be apprehensive in any respect about what it’d imply.
Snape’s Missing Ingredients
After the second activity, the place Harry makes use of gillyweed to breathe underwater, Snape corners Harry and accuses him of stealing from his private potions shops. Even if he did not steal the gillyweed Snape can also be lacking boomslang pores and skin and lacewing flies.
Why are these components necessary? Snape being an expert teacher in potions explains that they make the polyjuice potion and he is satisfied that Harry and pals are brewing some. If Harry had thought-about the flask habits maybe he would have been in a position to query Moody’s id when it nonetheless would have finished some good.
The Defense Against The Dark Arts Position Is Cursed
Even by his fourth 12 months, Harry Potter ought to have realized that one thing is improper with the Defense Against The Dark Arts class. Every 12 months, the professor of this class has been both a villain or with one thing to make them unable to remain.
Professor Moody was one more in an extended line of villains and antagonists to show the category together with Professor Quirinus Quirrell, Gilderoy Lockhart, and even Remus Lupin in his werewolf kind. As confirmed, Harry is way from a detective however he ought to have no less than suspected the strangest Defense Against The Dark Arts instructor but of being a perpetrator.
The Tongue Tic
It could also be movie canon solely however that tongue flick is especially particular and obvious each when Harry sees Barty Crouch Jr. in Dumbledore’s Pensieve and when Moody speaks with Harry and Barty Crouch Sr. within the Forbidden Forest. Once once more Harry would not put the items collectively.
The largest trace ought to have been after Harry noticed Barty Crouch Jr. show the identical tic after he was uncovered in Dumbledore’s reminiscence. Moody had finished the identical factor a number of occasions by that time and Harry Potter would not even start to really feel any suspicion.
Twisted Teaching Methods
Granted, a sensible strategy in instructing college students concerning the worst curses in idea is just not a foul one. However, Alastor Moody decides to show the scholars by traumatizing them with disturbing examples of what the curses can do, together with showcasing to Neville Longbottom the same curse used on his parents.
He might have used the curses on a spider however it was clear that this pretend Moody was getting an excessive amount of pleasure and pleasure out of displaying these fourth-year college students these curses. While it’s stated that Moody is eccentric therefore his nickname, even Harry ought to have been a little bit suspicious.
Moody Took The Marauder’s Map In The Book
There are a number of differences between the Goblet Of Fire book and movie versions. The Marauder’s Map was in a position to establish Peter Pettigrew even when he was in his animagus kind, it should not have been an issue to establish somebody disguised by polyjuice potion.
In the Goblet Of Fire e book, Moody correctly borrows the map from Harry when he realizes its powers, however Harry by no means asks for it again. He by no means considers that the map confirmed somebody named Barty Crouch in Snape’s potion shops. As the viewers was knowledgeable in Prisoner of Azkaban, that the map by no means lies. Harry ought to have remembered that.
When Moody Takes Harry From Dumbledore
Harry was in shock, little doubt about it when he returned to high school clutching the physique of Cedric Diggory however, as Voldemort had actually simply returned, he in all probability ought to have clutched on the hem of Dumbledore’s robes and by no means let go.
Instead, Moody inexplicably guides Harry away from Dumbledore, and all different eyes, and get him to his personal non-public workplace. This is, after all, the motion that lastly clues Dumbledore into the false Moody of their midst, however it nonetheless wasn’t sufficient for Harry.
Every Star Wars Retcon & Lore Change In 2021
About The Author